Topic lessonTopic: IAM: identity and permissions
Troubleshoot IAM AccessDenied: requests, allows, denies and limits
AccessDenied means an AWS request was not authorized. Before adding permissions, identify the failed principal, action and resource. A mismatched statement, an explicit Deny and a permissions limit require different investigations even when the visible error looks similar.
Separate observed denial from an assumed cause, collect the necessary evidence and narrow down the control that needs review.
Know Effect, Action and Resource. Do not submit confidential errors or real policies to this site.
First isolate one failed request
A console screen can call several APIs. “The S3 screen failed” does not distinguish listing from retrieving an object. Use authorized administrative tools to establish the failed API, its target and the actual requesting identity. A different successful operation does not establish access for this request.
| Item | Record | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Principal | The actual requesting identity and session | App using the reporting role |
| Action and resource | The failed API and its target | GetObject / report.csv |
| Context | Timing, reproduction and relevant error detail | Repeated denial for the same request |
| Unknowns | Controls and conditions not yet inspected | Organization limits awaiting administrator review |
Use the error to choose what to inspect
- Denied request → Statement matchingInspect mismatches and missing grants
- Denied request → Other controls / limitsCheck restrictions as well as allows
- Denied request
- Keep principal, action and target fixed.
- Statement matching
- Compare Action, Resource and Condition.
- Other controls / limits
- Inspect applicable denies, boundaries and organization limits.
An error naming a policy type or reason is useful evidence. It is not necessarily an exhaustive list of restrictions. Fixing one issue can expose another denial. A control you have not inspected must not be assumed absent.
Separate explicit denial from a missing grant
| Evidence | Interpretation | Next check |
|---|---|---|
| An applicable explicit Deny | An Allow cannot override it | Review the deny’s purpose and scope with its administrator |
| No required Allow | A grant may be missing | Identify the necessary action, resource and conditions |
| Outside an applicable permissions limit | A grant alone is insufficient | Review the limit against the requirement |
| Relevant policies cannot be inspected | The cause remains unproven | Ask an authorized administrator to investigate |
Make a bounded change and verify the intended request
- Check whether the failed request is actually required by the task.
- Find evidence for the suspected policy or condition; involve its administrator when necessary.
- Define the target, impact and rollback for a reviewed change.
- Verify both the intended request and requests that must remain unauthorized.
Do not turn missing context into a confirmed cause
Choose an option to see the result and explanation.
The IAM lab lets you compare explicit denial, missing permission and incomplete context within a bounded model. An indeterminate lab result is not an observed AWS denial. Keep the exercise result separate from a real investigation.
Check, then explain in your own words
- Record principal, action and resource for the failed request.
- Separate supported causes from controls still uninspected.
- Compare explicit denial and missing context in the IAM lab.
Check your understanding: The same Allow was added again and the request still fails. What next?
Inspect request matching and other applicable controls using evidence.
Duplicate Allows do not remove an applicable Deny. Avoid assuming an unknown restriction is simply a missing grant.
Sources and conditions checked
The official references used in this lesson are collected here with their scope, conditions and corresponding sections. Independent expert review and live AWS comparison have not been performed.
- Troubleshoot access deniedChecked:
Scope and conditionsMessages can identify only part of the effective denial context
Used in this lessonFirst isolate one failed request Use the error to choose what to inspect Separate explicit denial from a missing grant Do not turn missing context into a confirmed cause
- IAM policy evaluation logicChecked:
Scope and conditionsPolicy types and context matter; identity-only lab is a subset
Used in this lessonFirst isolate one failed request Use the error to choose what to inspect Separate explicit denial from a missing grant Do not turn missing context into a confirmed cause