Core lesson 13 of 18Topic: S3: storage and access
S3 public-access lab: compare policy writes and object reads
Compare a bucket-policy write (PutBucketPolicy) and an object read (GetObject) under separate teaching assumptions. This is not a data-upload exercise. Change one BPA or request condition and inspect the result and reason locally in your browser.
Identify the conditions relevant to the selected operation and explain a policy-write result separately from an object-read result.
Know buckets, keys and the four BPA settings. No real bucket is modified and no real object is retrieved.
First choose which operation to study
- Choose an operation → PutBucketPolicyInspect a proposed access-rule write
- Choose an operation → GetObjectInspect a read under existing settings
- Choose an operation
- Keep policy writes separate from object reads.
- PutBucketPolicy
- Proposed policy, requester, IAM grant and three modeled policy-write block levels.
- GetObject
- Anonymous request, existing policy, existence, read restrictions and out-of-scope context.
The lab does not enact a real write followed by a read. Read cases have their own existing-policy assumptions. When moving to another operation, reread its name and current conditions first.
Change one condition and compare the reason
| Try | Observe |
|---|---|
| Evaluate a guided policy-write case | Which conditions affect the proposed write |
| Change one policy-write BPA block | How the write reason changes for the same request |
| Choose a guided read case | The anonymous requester and existing-policy assumptions |
| Set existence or external context to unknown | Missing context or unsupported scope, rather than a blanket denial |
Changing the operation reevaluates the selected operation. Check the operation and reason together rather than reusing an explanation from the previous one. Other edits mark the previous result stale; reevaluate when required.
Read the outcome within the model’s scope
| Display | What it establishes | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Exercise conditions met | The bounded modeled requirements are satisfied | No actual policy save or HTTP 200 was verified |
| Exercise conditions not met | A requirement within scope fails | This is not an exhaustive inventory of real AWS restrictions |
| Missing context / outside scope | Necessary information or supported semantics are absent | Do not turn unknown into allowed or denied |
| Invalid input | Malformed input was not evaluated | It does not describe accepted AWS input |
Check whether writes and reads remain separate
Choose an option to see the result and explanation.
- Read the operation and conditions in a guided case below.
- Change one fact, predict and evaluate.
- Explain the reason and name a real-world condition the lab does not verify.
Check, then explain in your own words
- Identify policy-write and object-read operations.
- Change one condition and compare the reason.
- Keep model outcomes separate from real AWS success and HTTP responses.
Check your understanding: A policy-write case meets the exercise conditions. Was a real bucket policy saved?
No. It is a browser-local teaching result.
The lab does not connect to AWS or write policies or data. Model evaluation and actual operation outcomes are distinct.
Try different conditions
Compare fixed synthetic conditions locally. No real AWS operations, input persistence or input transmission occur.
Loading exercise…
Sources and conditions checked
The official references used in this lesson are collected here with their scope, conditions and corresponding sections. Independent expert review and live AWS comparison have not been performed.
- S3 Block Public AccessChecked:
Scope and conditionsFour controls, applicable levels and most restrictive combination
Used in this lessonLesson overview and review
- Troubleshoot S3 403 errorsChecked:
Scope and conditionsAPI, principal, policies, encryption and access path
Used in this lessonLesson overview and review